Files
crank/apps/admin-api/tests/integration/resources/draft_updates.rs
T
Hermes DevOps 75fe5a123c [skip ci] wip: preserve Hermes crank development checkpoint
Owner-authorized recovery of accumulated source changes.
Includes accepted work and in-progress changes; NOT a release or acceptance.
Parent baseline 1b6db09bd1. Runtime data, build caches and local credentials excluded.
2026-10-25 10:00:22 +00:00

795 lines
27 KiB
Rust
Raw Blame History

This file contains ambiguous Unicode characters
This file contains Unicode characters that might be confused with other characters. If you think that this is intentional, you can safely ignore this warning. Use the Escape button to reveal them.
//! P2 (affected ATDD до исправления) и R-E: порядок клиентских отказов, immutable-
//! presence, реальный CAS и наблюдение полного состояния после каждого отказа.
//! Источники: CORRECTION-PACKAGE P2 (TL F02/F03/F04/F07, QA F-STALE), SPEC v4
//! D-14/D-16/D-20, TL review run103 R-E. Подмодуль `tests/integration/resources.rs`.
use super::helpers::{
assert_draft_identity, create_draft, created_resource_id, draft_form, draft_metadata,
draft_updated_at, error_signature, get_card, post_draft_raw, read_content, read_response,
spawn_authorized, table_row_count,
};
use super::{observe_draft_state, put_draft_raw, update_metadata};
use reqwest::StatusCode;
use serde_json::{Value, json};
use serial_test::serial;
#[tokio::test(flavor = "multi_thread")]
#[serial]
async fn story36_at02_unknown_kind_is_generic_validation_error() {
let (registry, server, client) = spawn_authorized("story36_unknown_kind").await;
// D-20 шаг B: неизвестный kind — отказ формы запроса, а не Resource-специфичный код.
let meta = draft_metadata(
"crank://unknown/kind",
"unknown_kind",
"video",
"video/mp4",
"internal",
);
let (status, _, text, body) =
post_draft_raw(&client, &server, &meta, b"payload", "video/mp4").await;
assert_eq!(
status,
StatusCode::BAD_REQUEST,
"unknown kind must be a client rejection (D-20 B); observed {} body={text}",
error_signature(status, &body)
);
assert_eq!(
body["error"]["code"],
json!("validation_error"),
"unknown kind belongs to step B and must not get a Resource-specific code (P2); body={text}"
);
assert_eq!(table_row_count(registry.pool(), "resources").await, 0);
}
#[tokio::test(flavor = "multi_thread")]
#[serial]
async fn story36_at02_unknown_sensitivity_is_client_rejection_not_internal_error() {
let (registry, server, client) = spawn_authorized("story36_unknown_sensitivity").await;
// D-20 шаг E: неизвестная sensitivity — клиентский отказ на своём месте, не storage 500 (P2).
let meta = draft_metadata(
"crank://unknown/sensitivity",
"unknown_sensitivity",
"text",
"text/plain",
"top_secret",
);
let (status, text, body) = read_response(
client
.post(format!("{server}/resources"))
.multipart(draft_form(&meta, b"payload", "draft.txt", "text/plain"))
.send()
.await
.expect("draft request must complete"),
)
.await;
assert_eq!(
status,
StatusCode::BAD_REQUEST,
"unknown sensitivity must be a client rejection, not a storage failure (D-20 E); observed {} body={text}",
error_signature(status, &body)
);
assert_ne!(
body["error"]["code"],
json!("resource_storage_unavailable"),
"an unknown user-supplied enum value must never surface as an internal error (P2); body={text}"
);
assert_eq!(table_row_count(registry.pool(), "resources").await, 0);
}
#[tokio::test(flavor = "multi_thread")]
#[serial]
async fn story36_at02_immutable_fields_present_as_null_or_wrong_type_are_rejected() {
let (registry, server, client) = spawn_authorized("story36_immutable_presence").await;
let mut observations: Vec<String> = Vec::new();
let mut mismatches: Vec<String> = Vec::new();
// D (D-20): присутствие ключа — уже нарушение неизменяемости, независимо от значения.
// Каждый null-вектор исполняется на **своём** свежем Draft с собственной precondition и
// собственным полным «до»: принятый `uri: null` иначе изменил бы состояние и сделал бы
// следующие случаи двухфакторными (R-E, TL run105 F1).
for field in ["uri", "name", "kind"] {
let (id, updated_at, before) = case_draft(
&registry,
&client,
&server,
"presence",
&format!("null_{field}"),
)
.await;
let mut metadata = update_metadata("", "text/plain", "internal", &updated_at);
metadata[field] = Value::Null;
let (status, _text, body) = put_draft_raw(
&client,
&server,
&id,
&metadata,
b"second body",
"text/plain",
)
.await;
let after = observe_draft_state(&registry, &client, &server, &id).await;
record_case(
&mut observations,
&mut mismatches,
&format!("present-but-null-{field}"),
status,
&body,
after == before,
StatusCode::BAD_REQUEST,
ExpectedCode::Exact("resource_field_immutable"),
Some(field),
);
}
// B (D-20): неверный JSON-тип каждого immutable-ключа — отказ формы запроса с точным
// generic-кодом и наблюдением неизменного состояния. Изоляция случаев та же (F1).
for (field, value) in [
("uri", json!(5)),
("name", json!([1, 2])),
("kind", json!({"object": true})),
] {
let (id, updated_at, before) = case_draft(
&registry,
&client,
&server,
"presence",
&format!("type_{field}"),
)
.await;
let mut metadata = update_metadata("", "text/plain", "internal", &updated_at);
metadata[field] = value;
let (status, _text, body) = put_draft_raw(
&client,
&server,
&id,
&metadata,
b"second body",
"text/plain",
)
.await;
let after = observe_draft_state(&registry, &client, &server, &id).await;
record_case(
&mut observations,
&mut mismatches,
&format!("wrong-type-{field}"),
status,
&body,
after == before,
StatusCode::BAD_REQUEST,
ExpectedCode::Exact("validation_error"),
None,
);
}
assert!(
mismatches.is_empty(),
"every null/wrong-type immutable case must be independently observed with its exact code \
and an unchanged full state; observations: {observations:?}; mismatches: {mismatches:?}"
);
}
#[tokio::test(flavor = "multi_thread")]
#[serial]
async fn story36_at02_update_without_immutable_fields_is_accepted() {
let (_registry, server, client) = spawn_authorized("story36_immutable_absent").await;
// Положительный контроль к негативам выше: отсутствие ключей — валидное обновление.
let meta = draft_metadata(
"crank://immutable/absent",
"immutable_absent",
"text",
"text/plain",
"internal",
);
let created = create_draft(
&client,
&server,
&meta,
b"first body",
"draft.txt",
"text/plain",
)
.await;
let id = created_resource_id(&created);
let updated_at = draft_updated_at(&get_card(&client, &server, &id).await);
let metadata = update_metadata("updated description", "text/plain", "internal", &updated_at);
let (status, text, body) = put_draft_raw(
&client,
&server,
&id,
&metadata,
b"second body",
"text/plain",
)
.await;
assert_eq!(
status,
StatusCode::OK,
"absent immutable keys must be a valid update (D-16); observed {} body={text}",
error_signature(status, &body)
);
let card = get_card(&client, &server, &id).await;
assert_draft_identity(
&card,
"crank://immutable/absent",
"immutable_absent",
"text",
);
assert_eq!(
card["resource"]["description"],
json!("updated description")
);
assert_eq!(card["version"]["version"], json!(2));
assert_eq!(
read_content(&client, &server, &id).await,
b"second body".to_vec(),
"the accepted update must switch the served bytes"
);
}
#[tokio::test(flavor = "multi_thread")]
#[serial]
async fn story36_at04_stale_precondition_precedes_content_validation() {
let (registry, server, client) = spawn_authorized("story36_stale").await;
let meta = draft_metadata(
"crank://stale/draft",
"stale_draft",
"text",
"text/plain",
"internal",
);
let created = create_draft(
&client,
&server,
&meta,
b"first body",
"draft.txt",
"text/plain",
)
.await;
let id = created_resource_id(&created);
let first = draft_updated_at(&get_card(&client, &server, &id).await);
// Принятое обновление делает `first` настоящим (ранее валидным, теперь stale) precondition.
let metadata = update_metadata("", "text/plain", "internal", &first);
let (status, text, _) = put_draft_raw(
&client,
&server,
&id,
&metadata,
b"second body",
"text/plain",
)
.await;
assert_eq!(
status,
StatusCode::OK,
"a fresh precondition must update the Draft; body={text}"
);
// F побеждает G: stale precondition + невалидная кодировка содержимого → 428, не 422.
let metadata = update_metadata("", "text/plain", "internal", &first);
let (status, text, body) = put_draft_raw(
&client,
&server,
&id,
&metadata,
&[0xC3, 0x28],
"text/plain",
)
.await;
assert_eq!(
status,
StatusCode::PRECONDITION_REQUIRED,
"the stale precondition must be decided before content validation (D-20 F); observed {} body={text}",
error_signature(status, &body)
);
assert_eq!(body["error"]["code"], json!("resource_stale"));
assert_eq!(
body["error"]["context"]["field"],
json!("expected_updated_at")
);
assert_eq!(body["error"]["context"]["recovery"], json!("reload"));
// ...и с валидным содержимым — тот же 428 (authoritative precondition).
let metadata = update_metadata("", "text/plain", "internal", &first);
let (status, text, body) = put_draft_raw(
&client,
&server,
&id,
&metadata,
b"third body",
"text/plain",
)
.await;
assert_eq!(
status,
StatusCode::PRECONDITION_REQUIRED,
"a stale precondition must be rejected regardless of content validity; observed {} body={text}",
error_signature(status, &body)
);
assert_eq!(body["error"]["code"], json!("resource_stale"));
// Отклонённые обновления не оставили принятой версии; прежние bytes читаются.
assert_eq!(
table_row_count(registry.pool(), "resource_versions").await,
2
);
assert_eq!(
read_content(&client, &server, &id).await,
b"second body".to_vec()
);
// Свежий precondition после отказов продолжает работать.
let current = draft_updated_at(&get_card(&client, &server, &id).await);
let metadata = update_metadata("", "text/plain", "internal", &current);
let (status, text, _) = put_draft_raw(
&client,
&server,
&id,
&metadata,
b"third body",
"text/plain",
)
.await;
assert_eq!(
status,
StatusCode::OK,
"a fresh precondition must still work after stale rejections: {text}"
);
assert_eq!(
read_content(&client, &server, &id).await,
b"third body".to_vec()
);
}
#[tokio::test(flavor = "multi_thread")]
#[serial]
async fn story36_at04_concurrent_updates_are_a_single_authoritative_cas() {
let (registry, server, client) = spawn_authorized("story36_cas").await;
let meta = draft_metadata(
"crank://cas/draft",
"cas_draft",
"text",
"text/plain",
"internal",
);
let created = create_draft(
&client,
&server,
&meta,
b"first body",
"draft.txt",
"text/plain",
)
.await;
let id = created_resource_id(&created);
let precondition = draft_updated_at(&get_card(&client, &server, &id).await);
let server_url = format!("{server}");
let attempt = |content: &'static [u8]| {
let client = client.clone();
let server = server_url.clone();
let resource_id = id.clone();
let metadata = update_metadata("", "text/plain", "internal", &precondition);
async move {
put_draft_raw(
&client,
&server,
&resource_id,
&metadata,
content,
"text/plain",
)
.await
}
};
// Два одновременных валидных обновления с одним precondition: ровно один принимается.
let left = attempt(b"left body");
let right = attempt(b"right body");
let outcomes = tokio::join!(left, right);
let outcomes = [outcomes.0, outcomes.1];
let accepted = outcomes
.iter()
.position(|(status, _, _)| *status == StatusCode::OK);
let stale = outcomes
.iter()
.filter(|(status, _, _)| *status == StatusCode::PRECONDITION_REQUIRED)
.count();
let observed = outcomes
.iter()
.map(|(status, _, body)| error_signature(*status, body))
.collect::<Vec<_>>()
.join(" | ");
assert!(
accepted.is_some(),
"exactly one concurrent update must be accepted: {observed}"
);
assert_eq!(
stale, 1,
"the loser must observe resource_stale: {observed}"
);
// Точный код проигравшей стороны, а не только статус (R-E).
let stale_outcome = outcomes
.iter()
.find(|(status, _, _)| *status == StatusCode::PRECONDITION_REQUIRED)
.expect("the losing attempt must be a stale rejection");
assert_eq!(
stale_outcome.2["error"]["code"],
json!("resource_stale"),
"the loser of the CAS must carry the authoritative resource_stale code: {observed}"
);
let winner: &[u8] = if accepted == Some(0) {
b"left body"
} else {
b"right body"
};
assert_eq!(
table_row_count(registry.pool(), "resource_versions").await,
2,
"one accepted update must create exactly one new version"
);
assert_eq!(
table_row_count(registry.pool(), "artifact_sources").await,
2
);
assert_eq!(
get_card(&client, &server, &id).await["version"]["version"],
json!(2)
);
assert_eq!(
read_content(&client, &server, &id).await,
winner.to_vec(),
"the served bytes must be the winner's, with no lost update"
);
}
// ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
// P2 remainder (TL review run101 R-E, TL review run103 R-E): неизвестные enum-значения
// на update, приоритет шагов D-20, immutable-ключи и наблюдение полного состояния
// после каждого отказа. Helper-ы/типы (`case_draft`, `ExpectedCode`, `CLIENT_CODES`,
// `record_case`) и лон-векторы F4 живут в private-подмодуле `observations`
// (health-лимит 1000 строк, R4 TL run113).
// ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
mod observations;
use observations::{ExpectedCode, case_draft, record_case};
#[tokio::test(flavor = "multi_thread")]
#[serial]
async fn story36_at02_update_unknown_enums_and_d20_precedence() {
let (registry, server, client) = spawn_authorized("story36_update_enums").await;
let meta = draft_metadata(
"crank://update/enums",
"update_enums",
"text",
"text/plain",
"internal",
);
let created = create_draft(
&client,
&server,
&meta,
b"first body",
"draft.txt",
"text/plain",
)
.await;
let id = created_resource_id(&created);
let updated_at = draft_updated_at(&get_card(&client, &server, &id).await);
// Якорь: наблюдаемое «до» — действительно принятое состояние, отказы которого
// проверяются ниже (иначе равенство «после == до» ничего не доказывало бы).
let before = observe_draft_state(&registry, &client, &server, &id).await;
assert_draft_identity(&before.card, "crank://update/enums", "update_enums", "text");
assert_eq!(before.card["version"]["version"], json!(1));
assert_eq!(before.bytes, b"first body".to_vec());
assert_eq!(before.versions, 1);
assert_eq!(before.owning_refs, 1);
let mut observations: Vec<String> = Vec::new();
let mut mismatches: Vec<String> = Vec::new();
// (B) неизвестный enum-`kind` на update — отказ формы запроса. Принятый D-20 B
// ставит неизвестный kind раньше C/D/E, поэтому ожидание — generic `validation_error`,
// а не `resource_field_immutable` (оракул шага D ставится на известный kind ниже).
let mut metadata = update_metadata("", "text/plain", "internal", &updated_at);
metadata["kind"] = json!("video");
let (status, _text, body) = put_draft_raw(
&client,
&server,
&id,
&metadata,
b"second body",
"text/plain",
)
.await;
let after = observe_draft_state(&registry, &client, &server, &id).await;
record_case(
&mut observations,
&mut mismatches,
"unknown-kind-on-update (B)",
status,
&body,
after == before,
StatusCode::BAD_REQUEST,
ExpectedCode::Exact("validation_error"),
None,
);
// (D) immutable `kind` с **известным** значением (json при kind=text) — отказ
// неизменяемости со своим полем, состояние не меняется.
let mut metadata = update_metadata("", "text/plain", "internal", &updated_at);
metadata["kind"] = json!("json");
let (status, _text, body) = put_draft_raw(
&client,
&server,
&id,
&metadata,
b"second body",
"text/plain",
)
.await;
let after = observe_draft_state(&registry, &client, &server, &id).await;
record_case(
&mut observations,
&mut mismatches,
"immutable-known-kind (D)",
status,
&body,
after == before,
StatusCode::BAD_REQUEST,
ExpectedCode::Exact("resource_field_immutable"),
Some("kind"),
);
// (E) неизвестная sensitivity — клиентский отказ своего шага, не storage 500.
let metadata = update_metadata("", "text/plain", "top_secret", &updated_at);
let (status, _text, body) = put_draft_raw(
&client,
&server,
&id,
&metadata,
b"second body",
"text/plain",
)
.await;
let after = observe_draft_state(&registry, &client, &server, &id).await;
record_case(
&mut observations,
&mut mismatches,
"unknown-sensitivity-update (E)",
status,
&body,
after == before,
StatusCode::BAD_REQUEST,
ExpectedCode::ClientRejectionExcept(&["resource_storage_unavailable", "internal_error"]),
None,
);
// (E) MIME, синтаксис которого верен, но которого нет ни в одном allowlist.
let metadata = update_metadata("", "video/mp4", "internal", &updated_at);
let (status, _text, body) = put_draft_raw(
&client,
&server,
&id,
&metadata,
b"second body",
"video/mp4",
)
.await;
let after = observe_draft_state(&registry, &client, &server, &id).await;
record_case(
&mut observations,
&mut mismatches,
"mime-not-allowed (E)",
status,
&body,
after == before,
StatusCode::BAD_REQUEST,
ExpectedCode::Exact("resource_mime_not_allowed"),
Some("mime_type"),
);
// D-20 precedence (D раньше E): immutable-ключ + неизвестная sensitivity в одном payload.
let mut metadata = update_metadata("", "text/plain", "top_secret", &updated_at);
metadata["uri"] = json!("crank://update/enums/other");
let (status, _text, body) = put_draft_raw(
&client,
&server,
&id,
&metadata,
b"second body",
"text/plain",
)
.await;
let after = observe_draft_state(&registry, &client, &server, &id).await;
record_case(
&mut observations,
&mut mismatches,
"precedence-D-over-E",
status,
&body,
after == before,
StatusCode::BAD_REQUEST,
ExpectedCode::Exact("resource_field_immutable"),
Some("uri"),
);
// D-20 precedence (E раньше F): неизвестная sensitivity + stale precondition.
let mut metadata = update_metadata("", "text/plain", "top_secret", &updated_at);
metadata["expected_updated_at"] = json!("1970-01-01T00:00:00Z");
let (status, _text, body) = put_draft_raw(
&client,
&server,
&id,
&metadata,
b"second body",
"text/plain",
)
.await;
let after = observe_draft_state(&registry, &client, &server, &id).await;
record_case(
&mut observations,
&mut mismatches,
"precedence-E-over-F",
status,
&body,
after == before,
StatusCode::BAD_REQUEST,
ExpectedCode::ClientRejectionExcept(&["resource_stale"]),
None,
);
// Положительный контроль: валидное обновление того же Draft проходит и меняет состояние —
// значит «неизменно» выше было наблюдением, а не неработающим обновлением.
let metadata = update_metadata("updated description", "text/plain", "public", &updated_at);
let (status, text, body) = put_draft_raw(
&client,
&server,
&id,
&metadata,
b"second body",
"text/plain",
)
.await;
assert_eq!(
status,
StatusCode::OK,
"a valid update must still succeed after the refusals: {}",
error_signature(status, &body)
);
assert!(
text.is_empty() || !text.contains("second body"),
"a successful card response must not echo content bytes: {text}"
);
let accepted = observe_draft_state(&registry, &client, &server, &id).await;
assert_ne!(
accepted, before,
"the accepted update must really change the observed state"
);
assert_eq!(accepted.card["version"]["version"], json!(2));
assert_eq!(accepted.bytes, b"second body".to_vec());
assert_eq!(accepted.versions, 2);
assert_eq!(accepted.owning_refs, 2);
assert_eq!(
accepted.card["resource"]["description"],
json!("updated description")
);
assert!(
mismatches.is_empty(),
"every refusal case must carry its exact stable code and leave the full state unchanged; \
observations: {observations:?}; mismatches: {mismatches:?}"
);
}
#[tokio::test(flavor = "multi_thread")]
#[serial]
async fn story36_at02_immutable_keys_present_as_strings_are_rejected_per_key() {
let (registry, server, client) = spawn_authorized("story36_immutable_strings").await;
let mut observations: Vec<String> = Vec::new();
let mut mismatches: Vec<String> = Vec::new();
// Каждый immutable-ключ со строковым значением: отказ D-16 со своим `field`,
// полное состояние наблюдается после каждого случая отдельно (per-case). Каждый случай
// идёт на своём свежем Draft, чтобы возможное принятие одного ключа не сделало
// следующий случай двухфакторным (TL run105 F1).
for (field, value) in [
("uri", "crank://immutable/presence/strings_other"),
("name", "immutable_presence_strings_renamed"),
("kind", "json"),
] {
let (id, updated_at, before) = case_draft(
&registry,
&client,
&server,
"strings",
&format!("str_{field}"),
)
.await;
let mut metadata = update_metadata("", "text/plain", "internal", &updated_at);
metadata[field] = json!(value);
let (status, _text, body) = put_draft_raw(
&client,
&server,
&id,
&metadata,
b"second body",
"text/plain",
)
.await;
let after = observe_draft_state(&registry, &client, &server, &id).await;
record_case(
&mut observations,
&mut mismatches,
&format!("immutable-{field}"),
status,
&body,
after == before,
StatusCode::BAD_REQUEST,
ExpectedCode::Exact("resource_field_immutable"),
Some(field),
);
}
// Неверный JSON-тип каждого immutable-ключа — отказ формы запроса (шаг B) с точным
// generic-кодом, а не только статусом; состояние тоже неизменно и изолировано.
for (field, value) in [
("uri", json!(5)),
("name", json!(["nested"])),
("kind", json!({"object": true})),
] {
let (id, updated_at, before) = case_draft(
&registry,
&client,
&server,
"strings",
&format!("type_{field}"),
)
.await;
let mut metadata = update_metadata("", "text/plain", "internal", &updated_at);
metadata[field] = value;
let (status, _text, body) = put_draft_raw(
&client,
&server,
&id,
&metadata,
b"second body",
"text/plain",
)
.await;
let after = observe_draft_state(&registry, &client, &server, &id).await;
record_case(
&mut observations,
&mut mismatches,
&format!("wrong-type-{field}"),
status,
&body,
after == before,
StatusCode::BAD_REQUEST,
ExpectedCode::Exact("validation_error"),
None,
);
}
assert!(
mismatches.is_empty(),
"every immutable-key case must carry its exact code/field and leave the full state \
unchanged; observations: {observations:?}; mismatches: {mismatches:?}"
);
}